Let's assumed I've asked a question which got quite a number of comments by other AD users trying to help me in narrowing down my problem and/or resolving it. I've partially answered the follow-up questions directly in the comments and partially edited my question to add additional information.
After a lot of back and forth, a moderator joined the discussion, temporarily closed the question and asked me to rework the question to reflect the newly gathered information before reopening it.
- Why is he doing that?
- What should I as an asker do now?
- Could there be better ways to handle such situations?
PS: This was inspired by this question but also is valid for similar issues we had in the past (and will have in the future).