2

The tag refers to using Apple operating systems on non-Apple hardware. Since this is explicitly off-topic on Ask Different, I would like to propose that be burninated.

| |
  • Let's use the tags tag for now to discuss burninate requests. – bmike Mar 14 '16 at 19:32
  • Sounds like a plan. – Tyll'a Mar 14 '16 at 19:32
-1

is gone, !

| |
  • That seems premature to act on a question unilaterally like that so quickly. I wish you had not. – Daniel Mar 16 '16 at 17:57
  • @Daniel There were three upvotes on the question indicating support and only two questions tagged with hackintosh, one of which was closed and the other shouldn't have had the tag in the first place on its own merits. I've responded to the points you made in your answer as a comment on your answer. – grg Mar 16 '16 at 18:18
  • For things which are not time-critical, please give the community a bit more time to reach an consensus than 2.5 hours. Upvoting a question doesn't imply support for the proposal described, we usually create a "yes" and a "no" answer for this (sometimes after a lengthy discussion) and have people vote on that. – nohillside May 15 '16 at 15:08
2

I'm usually the one arguing for tags to go away, but in this case, I'd rather see the hackintosh tag stay.

  • if all posts on the topic are indeed off-topic, the tag will only appear on off-topic posts. If such posts persist in the site, seeng they all have a common theme can help people know what is and is not off-topic

  • if off-topic posts are naturally deleted over time, the tag will die on its own when no surviving posts remain

  • our definition of on- and off-topic can change over time, and if posts are tagged as hackintosh, if the site later decides it wants to answer these, the tag marks them as a candidate for potential reopening.

Manually removing the tag from posts on which it belongs strikes me as a bad idea.

| |
  • I understand your arguments, but I do still think that burninating hackintosh was the right decision. All of the posts on the topic were indeed off-topic, and I don't see any reason why the off-topic posts should stay. They also didn't look like they would naturally go away over time. If hackintosh-related questions become on-topic, then I could see the tag coming back. As it is, I agree with @grgarside that burnination was the proper choice. – Tyll'a Mar 16 '16 at 17:59
  • There should not be off-topic questions posted on the site regardless of how they are tagged. Question askers can ask on meta using [asking-questions] for discussion regarding a potential question. Having a tag ‘just in case’ someone posts an off-topic question is poor practice. The tag has died on its own as its use on the two questions that I removed it from used it inappropriately or was closed. Using the tag as a ‘marker’ for later re-opening is ‘meta-tagging’, and such questions shouldn't be posted for the potential that they are later re-opened if the site scope changes. – grg Mar 16 '16 at 18:18
2

I think this is a big enough topic and different enough to include things that may be considered off-topic in AskDifferent, that it warrants it's own StackExchange.

And so, I present my proposal 🎉 Hackintosh Exchange (name pending)

Please come, vote, and contribute to the discussion.

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .