4

Is what I did in this question appropriate? Instead of editing the existing link-only answer, I made my own new answer with an explanation of the steps contained in the link. Is this fine? Or should I have just edited the other answer?

  • And actually, I went back and forth between keeping the link-only answer that way and editing it, but finally rolled back the edit and kept my answer there to help illustrate my point. – Andrew Larsson Mar 20 '16 at 4:11
3

As you haven't added any more information to your answer beyond what was obtained from the link, I would have edited the existing answer rather than adding a new one, but what you did is not wrong either.

If there had been other content in the existing answer then I would have added another answer as you did, but as it was just the link I would have added a quote or other derived content from the source to the existing answer. Additionally, if your answer had been longer and contained information from elsewhere including but not limited to personal experience, a new answer is definitely warranted.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .