9

I don't see a lot of questions (or answers) about Final Cut Pro X on the Apple Stack Exchange, and want to do something about that.

enter image description here

If you:

  • regularly do video editing
  • regularly participate in Ask Different
  • don't yet have a copy of Final Cut Pro X
  • would use one if you got it
  • would ask and answer questions about Final Cut Pro X on Ask Different

please answer this question. Early this week we will be sending out free, fully-licensed copies to the first 5 people who qualify.

  • I don't do video editing regularly, but I do occasionally. I would certainly ask and answer on Ask Different. In the unlikely event of there not being better-qualified people, I'm here :-). – Nathan Greenstein Jun 25 '11 at 14:51
  • I do video editing quite frequently (in school), but haven't got to try any software beyond iMovie. I would definitely ask questions, the software already looks difficult to use :/. On a side note, take a look at this article on CNET and this article on NYTimes. There seems that there is a lot of criticism about it – user6124 Jun 25 '11 at 15:23
  • 2
    @Nathan It might be nice to do a segment about it on the podcast – Kyle Cronin Jun 25 '11 at 16:12
  • 1
    I'd speculate that why we don't see questions about FCP here is because it's a specialized application one can build a career around. This is kind of like asking (though a bit reaching) for more Adobe inDesign questions for the Mac on Ask Different, but those questions are better suited over at Graphic Design due to its specialization and its community. I wonder if FCP questions and the surrounding issues are too specific or too deep for a general-use site like Ask Different, but I am all for more traffic. – Philip Regan Jun 25 '11 at 21:14
  • @Philip It's an Apple product, so it's by definition on topic for this site. I'd love to get more in-depth, technical questions about it here. – Kyle Cronin Jun 25 '11 at 22:47
  • @bckbck Per Joel's instructions, answer the question to throw your hat into the ring. The information in your comment makes you look like a perfect candidate (IMO). – Jason Salaz Jun 26 '11 at 1:09
  • @VxJasonxV with absolutely no experience or skill in using FCP X. I'd think that it would be better if there are some other people more suited for this, rather than me. – user6124 Jun 26 '11 at 1:19
  • @bckbck But that is the point. You don't have to have experience or skill using FCP X, you just have to have a need to edit videos and own a Mac capable of running FCP X. You will be given a copy, you use it, and when you run into problems, ask about it here. – Jason Salaz Jun 26 '11 at 2:00
  • @VxJasonxV I'll wait and see. If there are no other worthy people, then i will post it as an answer. – user6124 Jun 26 '11 at 2:18
  • 1
    this really belongs on the upcoming video site, I think – Jeff Atwood Jun 26 '11 at 10:02
  • @Kyle: I agree that FCP questions are technically on-topic for Ask Different, I'm just wondering how much traction they are really going to get even with this effort. Xcode is an highly specialized Apple product, but we don't get that many questions or answers about it directly. I'm not saying this is a bad idea, and is definitely worth a shot, but I just have a doubt the FCP community is going to follow along. Video-editing is a culture unto itself. – Philip Regan Jun 26 '11 at 11:23
  • @bckbck: I think you should answer with your comment anyway. You won't know unless you ask. – Philip Regan Jun 26 '11 at 11:26
  • bump........... – user6124 Jul 11 '11 at 9:18
  • How do I qualify? Or was this too long ago? – daviesgeek Oct 19 '11 at 16:06
  • @PhilipRegan Stack Overflow is a more suitable place for xCode and c+ developing. That is where I go for these answers and questions. – Graeme Hutchison Dec 6 '11 at 12:44
3

I regularly do software demo videos, screen casts that I splice together with audio and music. I do these with iMovie now. I would do them with FCPX if I had a copy. :)

2

If you:
regularly do video editing

I do video editing in school quite frequently, and haven't used anything better that iMovie (other than using FCP a few times on my friend's Mac). I would definitely want to try using FCP X for video editing.

regularly participate in Ask Different

Definitely.

don't yet have a copy of Final Cut Pro X

I don't have a copy of Final Cut Pro X.

would use one if you got it

I would use it, since iMovie lacks the tools which I need

would ask and answer questions about Final Cut Pro X on Ask Different

Of course, since the software already looks difficult to use :P

I'd be glad to participate :)

1

I would be very happy to participate!

  • 1
    ...and the answer to all 5 questions posed is yes. – bmike Jun 27 '11 at 22:26
1

There was a point when I looked into film production as a career, chiefly by starting my own production company, even going so far as to acquiring FCP when it first released along with some production equipment. I had done some work, but it was a lack of people resources that kept me from getting too far, so I put everything down and went forward with more stable ventures. That was about ten years go but I have still dabbled here and there in video and audio production as I got into multimedia for educational products.

Now, I really just want make videos of my kid(s), if only for the fact that my out-of-state and out-of-America family (which is pretty much everyone) has been practically begging for more videos. Using iMovie is a real drag, to me at least, I think because my first work with video was using Final Cut Pro. Using FCP compared to iMovie is a completely different mindset, one where I actually felt overly-guided in iMovie. I have read from a couple different sources speculation as to why FCPX wasn't released as a new version of FCP Express or a prosumer version of iMovie. It's an interesting point, and I have been wondering just how valid that really is.

Therefore, I would like to give this a go, should I qualify. I have a couple months before classes start again, and I would love a copy of FCP to work with for the benefit of familial relations and Ask Different promotion.

1

If this isn't over yet I would be interested in participating. I don't 'regularly' edit video, most of what I do in iMovie is home videos but I recently acquired a large collection of old super 8 film that needs to be sliced and diced.

I pretty regularly check Ask Different. I was a little more active today than usual but today is also Lion day.

I don't have a copy of FCPX, but would definitely use it if I had it.

I already have a few questions in mind for FCPX like: How picky is the Content Auto-Analysis, do people have to be in the shot the entire time for it to tag it properly? Same thing for zooming in on the subject, it is tagged as wide, medium or closeup?

1

I would be happy to help too! I really enjoy video editing. I use iMovie (not that much anymore), FCE 4, iDVD, and have used DVDSP some. And I would love to get a copy of FCPX because I don't have multi-cam editing on FCE (something which Apple has promised will come out in spring 2012)

0

This may be slightly late, I would happily participate in this.

I have a qulaification in Media production, which includes Video production. I use After Effects to create special effects as seen here on youtube.

  • I also use DVD Studio pro.
  • regularly do video editing for clients
  • regularly participate in Ask Different with over 600 rep last month
  • don't yet have a copy of Final Cut Pro X not yet, I have Express and Adobe Premiere
  • would use one if you got it, of course
  • would ask and answer questions about Final Cut Pro X on Ask Different, would be happy to ask and answer.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .