13

So what's the difference (assuming i'm asking an apple related question)?

7

If it's a Mac question, you may ask on whichever site you prefer. If it's not a Mac question, or if it involves other Apple devices with your Mac, you should ask it here.

  • 3
    It's not as cut and dried as that. SuperUser has active tags for iOS, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch, etc. And it does not exclude Apple device questions in the FAQ. – Jonathan Van Matre Dec 18 '11 at 14:29
6

The main rule at SuperUser is device questions have to be related to how they interface with the desktop. So ask your iOS-only questions here if it doesn't involve that.

Otherwise, since you can ask other questions either place really the question is

When is it best to ask at SuperUser vs. asking at AskDifferent?

Since SuperUser is right now the more populous and active site (150k visits daily to our 30k visits), I'd recommend....

  • Ask at SuperUser when it's the kind of question that would benefit from being seen/answered by a lot of people, and is not a question that requires much Apple-specific expertise.

  • Ask at SuperUser when it involves using Windows or Linux with something Apple, in particular if the "expert" part of the question needs a Windows or Linux expert more than it needs an Apple one.

  • Ask at AskDifferent when you need more technical Apple expertise, when your question would be answered by a "right" answer as opposed to a crowd-sourced list, or when your question is so keenly focused on Apple hardware/software/OS that this is the best place to get a good answer.

In short...

Ask where you think you're most likely to get a good answer.

  • 2
    You can ask about iOS devices on Super User only insofar as they interface with your computer (see superuser.com/faq). App recommendations for iOS devices are off topic there. – Kyle Cronin Dec 18 '11 at 15:41
  • Good point...I used a bad example. Still, there are iOS questions that can be asked there. – Jonathan Van Matre Dec 18 '11 at 16:31
  • 1
    Please provide examples of technically challenging questions that get answered on Apple.SE but not on SU. – Daniel Beck Jan 5 '12 at 21:24
4

From a Super User point of view: You can ask any question about computer hardware and software. This includes questions about your Mac, about Mac OS X, about Apple software, about software for Mac OS X, etc. Several users on SU are active in the related topics, so it's not like there's nobody to answer these questions.

Electronic devices are considered off topic, which includes all iOS devices and iPods, unless it's a home networking question or about interfacing with your computer. This means that, for example, Time Capsule and AirPort Express/Extreme are on topic, and questions about syncing your iPhone with your Mac, or backing up iOS data to your computer are fine. The line might be a bit blurry there, but the worst thing that can happen is that the question will be migrated here.

Another possible issue, and I have no idea how it's handled on Ask Different: Super User moderators don't really like software recommendation questions. If you just want to know what Twitter clients are available on OS X, and it's obvious you have not even bothered to use Google, the question will be closed quickly. My advice is to not ask "What software can do X", but instead ask "I have problem Y. How do I solve it on a Mac?"


Some people say that there are some topics where SU is better suited, and others where Ask Different is better suited, even though they are on topic on both sides. While this might be the case, you can freely choose which site you want to post on.

If a question doesn't get an answer on your chosen site for a few days, you can always request that a moderator moves it to another site. From my experience, these requests are always acted on quickly.

  • Similar policy here on the 'what twitter clients are there' questions. Generally, software recommendation questions need to demand a clear, specific featureset. You can't ask 'What are all the...' or 'What is the best...' – Nathan Greenstein Jan 5 '12 at 23:38

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .